Thursday, 16 August 2012

Review: The Glimpse by Claire Merle

Title: The Glimpse
Author: Claire Merle
Publisher: Faber & Faber
Published: June 07, 2012

Claire Merle’s debut novel is set in the UK, a place, which according to the Mental Health Foundation, will see 1 in 4 people experiencing some form of mental illness per year. It is also where I live. Interwoven into Merle’s book are nods to area names that I step foot in every day. The Glimpse takes place in only a small handful of decades from now. In other words, it is a story that could take place in my life time – and this is where I find myself being instantly distanced from the book. The thought of society reaching the point where segregation between those disposed to mental illness and those not becomes the best solution in such a short period of time is incredibly far-fetched. London, of all places, could never be so easily moulded into something that extreme so quickly. While the premise was definitely an interesting one, and also not anything I have encountered before, I was never quite fully convinced.

Although The Glimpse and I got off to a rocky start, I was willing to lose myself in the plot and focus on the good points. This, however, turned out to be quite a challenge. Tedious doesn’t quite cover it. Slow would be an understatement. Claire Merle is not a bad writer, and I have little criticism of the actual writing, but the plot failed to capture significant interest from me. Much of the story line is focused on Ana (the main character)’s attempt to locate her joining partner, Jasper Taurell after he goes missing. This endeavour means leaving the safety of the ‘Pure’ community to stay with the ‘Crazies’. Mostly, I struggled to maintain attentiveness (which is quite a task to accomplish when you care so little about what happens next).

The characters were a mixed bunch, some even quite likable, thankfully. Although my grasp on the secondary characters was a rather flimsy one, it was enough to satisfy me given my reaction to Ana. I fear she may have been somewhat to blame for my lack of interest in the story. Like the plot, she was flat. Forgettable is, unfortunately, quite a fitting word here. Where Ana was dull and one-dimensional, other characters in the book held more of my attention. Her father, for example, was a delight to try to figure out. He was complex – my varying impressions of him were turned on their head several times – and one of the more interesting characters who made this book very nearly worthwhile.

In the end, however, there were too few redeeming qualities to make this a satisfying reading experience. Not even the romance managed to win me over, with enigmatic Cole sweeping Ana off her feet. (There is a slight hint of a love triangle, but nothing of the hair-ripping variety). Having gained so little from this book, The Glimpse, quite clearly, was not meant for me. The sequel will be released in 2013 to form the final book of this duet. I doubt I will be picking it up (no matter how pretty the cover). 

Rating: 2 stars

44 comments:

  1. I love reading books set here so I can understand your delight in reading a book set where you live but unfortunately the rest of the book doesn't sound brilliant. It's a shame about the pacing, slow can work but not if it drags too much. Lovely, honest review, Sam!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to finish this book. :( It had a great premise and idea, but somehow, it just wasn't written in a way that captured my attention either. Glad to see that I'm not alone!

    Thanks for the honest review, Sam. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh, it's set where you live? interesting, I would love to experience that. Thanks for an honest review, Sam, sorry you didn't enjoy this more. I did like the book but more the second half the first half nearly put me to sleep. The whole idea does sound pretty bonkers though & I think it lacked believability. I totally agree with you about her dad! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sorry you didn't like this. I was turned off by the term "crazies". Not only is it insulting but it's also unoriginal. It's regretful that the heroine wasn't to your liking. In any book I read, the protag affects my overall judgement a lot.

    Thank you for the honest review though, Sam :D

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oh dear, this seems like it was quite a chore to get through! I'm glad that at least some of the characters were likable (the father sounds very interesting!) even if the main character was ultimately unforgettable. Sorry this didn't really work out for you but great, honest review. :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Oh no! I'd had high hopes for this, but as you reflect on the things that didn't work for you, I can see all of them annoying me, too. For example, the setting. I agree that it would be near impossible to change everybody in London into such segregation as explored here.

    It's such a shame the plot was a let down, where the writing wasn't actually bad! Though I do agree that this cover is super pretty.(: Thanks for your honest review, Sam!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I always find it hard to really enjoy a book where the main character lacks spunk. I'm sorry you had to feel like you were doing chores while you were reading this book.
    Fantastic review of candor Sam!

    ReplyDelete
  8. :( I'm sorry this didn't turn out well for you. Sounds like this book had quite a few major holes completely gaping open for readers to exit through. I really do think one of the biggies here is that the setting did not make you believe in it. Terribly wrong starting foot >_< Too bad that the main character was so flat too. I've read forgettable characters, but to have them 1D (lol, 1D, the other 1D)as well...

    Ah well, I liked your honesty in this well-written review (kept my attention the entire way through ^_^) and hope your next read is more enjoyable! <3

    ReplyDelete
  9. I can understand how turned off it may feel when the main character appears to be flat and one-dimensional. Hope you'll have a better reading experience with your next-read :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. I don't think I've seen a lot of positive things about this book, but I can see why from your review.
    Boo for the main character being uninteresting and boring. It really seems like you had to struggle to get through the book. If I was in your place, I probably wouldn't have had the courage to continue the book! :P
    At least some of the characters were likable! :/
    I'm sorry you didn't like this book, Sam. I most probably will not be picking this book up.
    Thank you for your honesty. :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. How I missed this review on GR?? Gah anyway I totally agree! The story is not so bad but a lot of different things make this book bad. At some point it was hard to read it, cause it's hard to get into something you don't like.

    Great review! :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think I would feel the same way reading something as close to me as this is to you. The impossibility of it would definitely bother me. And yet, I immediately thought of Slated with which there were no such problems. Maybe it's because it was set in a small town, a suburb or something, if I remember correctly. Huh. Anyway, I was pretty sure I wouldn't read this, but now I know I won't.
    Thanks for the detailed review, Sam!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Bummer! This is another book I have for review. The whole menal illness part intrigues me but after reading your review I am not so enthusasistc! I think you are like me right now, trying to get that TBR pile cleaned out!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Aww, I'm sorry you end up not liking this one, Sam. I was really interested about this when I first saw it in GR but after mixed reviews started popping up I'm not really sure if I'm going to pick this up. Thanks for the honest review, Sam. :)

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you very much for your honest and well written review! I've definitely been curious about this book ever since I've first seen it around, but it never interested me enough to get a copy. And after reading your review now, I'm not sure I'll ever end up reading it.

    Carina
    Fictional Distraction

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hmmmm. I don't mind slow as long as I feel like we're getting somewhere and the characters are utterly captivating. Like Maggie Stiefvater's books - they tend to be quite slow in terms of pacing, but she writes brilliant characters and I can't help but want to know more about them as we go along. I don't like to be bored, or worse, indifferent, and that sounds like it might be the case here. I think I'll skip this one, thanks for your thoughts Sam!

    ReplyDelete
  17. I'm sorry this one wasn't for you. To be honest, I don't think it would hold my attention, either. That cover sure is pretty, though. Wonderful and honest review, Sam! <3

    ReplyDelete
  18. Aw, and this looks so good! It's such a shame especially because it's actually set here for once. It really isn't a good sign when the MC is less interesting than a secondary character; I know what that experience is like. Sorry you didn't like it. Beautiful review, Sam! :)

    ReplyDelete
  19. Aw, it's a shame you didn't like this one more, Sam. I actually enjoyed it for its psychological aspect and while it's hard to imagine that segregation could occur in such a short time, never underestimate the power of authority :) In spite of people knowing about the Milgram experiment, his results are still replicated!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Darnnit! You no like it? Well, I haven't read it and I like helpful reviews like this one :) But it goes to say never to judge a book by its cover (<-- pfft, yah right ;D) Thanks for the review Sam! :D

    Shreya
    Chocolate Coated Reviews

    ReplyDelete
  21. That's unfortunate you didn't end up really liking this one. It's hard to care when characters are flat and forgettable. Great honest review, Sam. Thank goodness I didn't get this one to review! I will take a pass. :)

    ReplyDelete
  22. That's a shame, especially when the cover is so beautiful. I find the story of the book highly unlikely too as it runs along the lines of reality.

    It seems like there was just nothing in here that really worked for you. :C But your review was very honest & well-put. Hope your next read is a better one!

    ReplyDelete
  23. I'm sorry you didn't enjoy this book, Sam! I've heard mixed reviews on Glimpse and was apprehensive of starting the book. Sad that Ana came off as a flat character to you and that the romance was not enough to win you over. Although, I do agree with you that the book's premise sounds really interesting!

    Thank you for the awesome and honest review, Sam! ♥

    ReplyDelete
  24. Aww, sorry that you didn't enjoy this book, Sam! This book wasn't my favorite either. It's such a shame since the cover is really pretty, and the author seems very nice! I think my main problem is Ana too. I don't think I would like to be friends with her in real life. Sorry. :'(

    Anyway, thank you for the amazing review, Sam! <3 I really appreciate your honest thoughts. :)

    ReplyDelete
  25. I guess you would have enjoyed this a lot more if it focused on the secondary characters that you thought brought more to the story. I usually need to feel some sort of connection with the characters in order for a book to work for me, so the fact they fell flat for you, I definitely don't think they'd work for me either :( But thank you for checking this one out for us! :)

    ReplyDelete
  26. Oh well good because I DNFed this one. When you said it started rocky I thought you were gonna end up saying you glad you kept reading bc it ended up great >.< I found it very slow and kind of boring. I didn't really get into it at all and I think I stopped at like 25% which is the earliest I've ever called it quits on a book. It didn't offer anything unique for a dystopian. I also found the MC pretty forgettable. Thanks for taking one for the team, Sam! ;) Fabulous review, as always! Btw - I had nominated you for Best Review in the bloggy awards! :) You rock them!!

    ReplyDelete
  27. Awwwwwww...I'm sorry you didn't enjoy this one :( It's such a pity Ana was a forgettable character and the plot was disappointing. I probably won't enjoy this either, but since I received this from the publisher, I'll probably still read it one day. Thank you for the honest review Sam! :)

    ReplyDelete
  28. Sorry you didn't like this one, Sam! It does look pretty frustrating, and though I haven't read it, I agree with you - London wouldn't turn into something like this so quickly... this book just screams "lack of a proper world-building", from what I've heard about it. Anyway... from your review, I'm pretty sure I won't be picking this up anytime soon. Thank you for your honest review on it! :D

    ReplyDelete
  29. How interesting that this story is told in the place where you live. It should be fun to read about that :) That's why it's such a shame that you didn't like it. It's always a pity when things are just too unbelievable. Thanks for the review. I still have a copy from this book, so I will try it out, but I'm going to keep this in mind :)

    ReplyDelete
  30. Unfortunately I couldn't even get past the second chapter with this book. I'm glad to hear you could keep going, but it's a shame you didn't enjoy it in the end. It was a book that wasn't for me, even if it did have a UK based theme.

    ReplyDelete
  31. I think that was my big issue with this story, the slow pace. I dnf.
    Thanks for review, though,
    Brandi from Blkosiner’s Book Blog

    ReplyDelete
  32. I'm reading this soon, so, i will keep these points in my mind. Thanks for the review! =D

    ReplyDelete
  33. Wow, seems that this one is a dud for a lot of people. I thought it sounded pretty interesting, but guess maybe it's not.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Sorry this one didn't work out for you, Sam! Hopefully your next read will be better. I have the Glimpse on my kindle as an e-ARC and have seen the mixed reviews. A lot of my trusted reviewers are not very impressed with it. :(

    ReplyDelete
  35. I've seen quite a mix of opinions on this, from complete love to... well, not so love. Sorry you were in the latter group, especially with such an intriguing premise.

    Such a significant part of loving a story is to have an interest in the main character, whether you love them or just fascinated by their evil, evil ways, you still need that connection. So it's disappointing that Ana failed to pull you in. Her father sounds interesting, though. Anyway, fabulous review, Sam! May your next read blow you away with it's awesomeness :D

    ReplyDelete
  36. ehh.. i hate it when books are just forgettable for me! I'm sorry you didn't like this book though! I really liked the cover, but I dont think i'll be reading this! Thanks for the honest review!
    Farah @MajiBookshelf

    ReplyDelete
  37. Aww, it's a shame that you didn't enjoy this book. I was actually thinking about purchasing it, but I after reading your review I don't think it's really my kind of book.

    Great review as always, Sam! :)

    ReplyDelete
  38. bummer you did like this book. tnx for the great review sam. i \m getting picky w/ dystopian books

    ReplyDelete
  39. Aw, it's a real shame you didn't enjoy this one! One of the things I hate the most about a book is when it is tedious and slow. I just want to throw the book out of the window.

    I've been seeing this alot and actually almost bought it a couple of weeks ago, but am now glad I decided not to. Thanks for your wonderful, honest review, Sam. :) xxx

    ReplyDelete
  40. So sad to see you didn't enjoy this more. Pacing is important to me, but with a good character, I can forgive a slow book. This seems to have had neither, which must have made for a harrowing experience. Being a rabid psychology fanatic, I'll probably still pick it up someday. But not sure if I'll be rushing to do so. Nice honest review.

    C.J.
    cjlistro.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  41. I requested this on Netgalley awhile ago but ended up declining it after I realized that "crazies" was a derogatory phrase used to group all people with mental disabilites as dangerous, and entirely incapable of living in a normal society. That was my take anyway, after reading the blurb and first few chapters. So I'm not surprised that you didn't like this Sam. It's too bad- that cover is lovely, but alas, it was not meant to be.. Lovely review, regardless. :)

    I believe I'll be including this in my pile of dystopian novels with sketchy world-building and/or typical romantic cliches... It's growing by the day, I tell you!

    ReplyDelete
  42. Oh, no. I'm so sorry this was a disappointment, Sam. :( I've read many other disappointed reviews, too. It seems like this book is just boring, which is always a shame. Especially when the concept is rather intriguing! Hopefully your next read will be much better, Sam! Thanks for the honest and well-written review. :)

    ReplyDelete
  43. I've read some reviews that had problems with the world building in The Glimpse and it sucks that the characters were not enough to redeem this book. Characters make the books for me so I can see myself not being able to finish it if I'm unable to connect with them.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Love your review, Sam. <3 Sucks that you didn't like the book, though. But also kind of glad, cause now I won't ever pick it up (A) lol :D So thank you for writing an honest review :)

    ReplyDelete

Comments are more than welcome. I read and appreciate them all, so do feel free to share your thoughts. If you are unsure about something and/or are leaving a question, I will respond to within a couple of days. Be sure to check back!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...