Friday, 20 April 2012

Review: Saving Francesca by Melina Marchetta

Title: Saving Francesca
Author: Melina Marchetta
Publisher: Knopf Books for Young Readers
Published: Dec 18, 2007 (first published 2003)
Find On: Goodreads | The Book Depository

Melina Marchetta writes like a god, there’s no denying it. Having read both 
On the Jellicoe Road and Finnikin of the Rock, I knew with near certainty that Saving Francesca would be just as spectacular as those books. How does she do it? I have never been so in awe of a writer’s writing before, but Melina Marchetta does not disappoint. Every single time I read something by her, I find myself sinking into each page, becoming lost among her poignant, humorous, and unequivocally real sentences. I want her to write hundreds and hundreds of books, to never stop writing, because there really should be more books like hers in the world.

Saving Francesca is a remarkable story that I will treasure and remember for a long time. Francesca, our protagonist, is a girl stuck at a boy’s school, with her old friends slipping away from her, and her new ones proving to be a mismatched, antagonistic bunch. There is Tara Finke the 'resident psycho, full of feminist, communist, anythingist rhetoric', Siobhan Sullivan, supposedly 'the biggest slut in the whole wide world', and Justine Kalinsky, the geeky accordion player who wants people to see her as their ‘rock’. Then there are the boys, Thomas Mackee, who happens to have a noteworthy flair for burping 'Teenage Dirtbag', Jimmy Hailler, the boy who invites himself round for dinner, and Will Trombal, the final member of six-people-I-most-want-to-be-friends-with. 

Without a doubt, the characters and their relationships are what makes this gem shine so brightly. From Thomas making me laugh when he calls Francesca’s nonno 'no-no' to Jimmy Hailler proving even strange boys like himself can offer much needed friendship, I found myself appreciating each and every quality of the characters. It’s extraordinary to watch the feelings between them all blossom and grow, to develop into something unmistakably special, that even I, as the reader, felt like these people were everything I wanted and needed without having realised it. 

It’s strange that I have taken such a strong shine to this wonderful set of characters, when they are all so flawed and full of numerous unlikable traits. Or perhaps that’s the reason why I did appreciate them so greatly. Melina Marchetta is the master of layered characters and she proves that again in this book. With parents who have both good and bad qualities and friends who are anything but perfect, Saving Francesca merges all the lines between stereotypical and clichéd characters, creating an array of diverse personalities and traits. 

It’s so easy to lose yourself in this book, to read it all in one sitting (which I’m certain I would have done had my body not felt the need to shut down during my late night reading session). While Jellicoe Road still remains my favourite of Merchetta’s books, Saving Francesca makes a close second. It has also made me realise I clearly can’t be trusted to decide which books I will read and when as Saving Francesca, I’m ashamed to admit, was not initially in my ‘top priority’ bubble. The whole ‘kicking myself for not having read it sooner’ thing applies here now more than ever. Though mark my word, Froi of the Exiles and The Piper's Son will be working their way up to the top of my list – I feel like I remember why I love reading every time I pick up a Melina Marchetta book.


Rating: 4.5 stars

24 comments:

  1. I hated On The Jellicoe Road even though I seem to be the only one! :( I think I should give Marchetta's books another go though since everyone adores them. I'll definitely get a copy of Saving Francesca! Great review Sam :D

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ahh I have been meaning to read a Melina Marchetta books a try because everyone positively loves her! I think I'm going to try this one first, definitely going near the top of my TBR list after your review. Even from your review, I can tell how vivid characters are! I like that they're flawed but still lovable anyway. I can't wait to read this book. Magnificent review, Sam!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I haven't read any of her books yet but I hear such great things!!! This is definitely one that appeals to me the most. It sounds like a fun read. Great review! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Excellent review Sam! I so love Melina Marchetta books. That woman needs to hurry up and write some more! So glad you liked this one. I laugh every time I think of that "psycho Tara"! There's a funny line in The Piper's Son about Thomas calling Tara that and what his sister interpreted as. Can't wait to see what you think of that one. :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Alright i need an honest answer. If she writes like a god, which amazing book do I read first? Your review has finally pushed me over the edge. I have to read one of these. But the question that's left is what? Jelliocoe Road or one of the others?

    Haley@www.passingthepages.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm going to say Jellicoe Road - only because I loved that the most! :) But once you're done with that, you should definitely give Finnikin and this one a try. :)

      Delete
  6. I LOVE MELINA MARCHETTA! I really adore her writing and I really loved Saving Francesca too though I think I loved The Piper's Son a little bit more since Tom is one of my favourite characters from Saving Francesca. My favourite Marchetta book is On the Jellicoe Road, just like you!

    Hope you can read The Piper's Son soon, Sam! Awesome review and glad you enjoyed it! ♥

    ReplyDelete
  7. I haven't read any of the books from the author, but it looks like I should be checking them out. I'm so glad you loved this one, Sam. Yes, I think we tend to love characters all the more when they are flawed, because no-one is perfect really, makes them seem more real. Thanks for this lovely review :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I guess Marchetta's writing inspired you, Sam, because you wrote an absolutely wonderful review. One of your best, I dare say.
    I must be the only person on the planet who wasn't blown away by this book. I prefer Looking for Alibrandi, but most of all, I'm a fan of Marchetta's fantasy work. Still, I'm getting ready to reread them all, maybe I'll feel differently the second time.
    So happy you enjoyed it, Sam.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Yay! Awesome review, Sam :) I also adore Melina's writing. <3 Although I don't think I will like her other books :p but maybe. This does sound like an very interesting book; just wouldn't be something I would like these days :) Maybe soon :D You need to read Froi soon! It is so amazing and so heartbreaking and just a must read. <3

    ReplyDelete
  10. First of all, your review is gorgeous.

    And second of all, I need to read this book.

    Actually. Scratch that. I need to read ALL of her books. This, Looking for Alibrandi, Finnikin and Froi, The Piper's Son. Very rarely do authors so impress me with one novel that I'm determined to read everything they've ever written, but Melina Marchetta did it. She has such a cult following for a reason; she's absolutely fantastic. And I think we should all make it our goal in life to read as many MM books as we possibly can.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Wow. What an amazing review, it makes me want to read this book as soon as possible. I had Saving Francesca on my TBR list long ago, but I think I completely forgot about it.

    Right now I'm craving a book that will make me love its characters, and I think this might be the perfect one! The way you described them... I loved it! And if you really liked the author's writing, that's even better. I saw your recommendation, so I think I'll start with On the Jellicoe Road :)

    Thanks for yet another amazing review! <3

    ReplyDelete
  12. Somehow I lived my life without knowing how genius Melina Marchetta is! I don't know how it happened -- especially with how much everyone talks about Jellicoe Road -- but your beautiful review (once again!) has me thinking that I need to change that ASAP! :)

    And it's not just the fun cover that makes me smile, but the idea of one girl in an all-boys school too! It kind of makes me think of the movie She's the Man in a totally unrelated way that probably has nothing to do with it except the fact that it's brilliant fun LOL x) I have a feeling I'll be smiling a lot while reading this book (and the characters like Tara), which makes me want to read it more because I LOVE to smile! :D

    Amazing review, Sam! This is a totally constant response to your reviews <3

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great review, Sam! I remember starting this a while back but not being able to get into it at the time. You've totally reminded me that I need to give this one another shot. :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Awesome review Sam. You always manage to make books I don't think I'd be interested in sound amazing lol. I haven't heard of Melina Marchetta before, but I think I'll have to give her a try.

    ReplyDelete
  15. As strange as it sounds, your review leaves me breathtaking, Sam. I don't know what I would do without your reviews LOL! I remember that I enjoyed this book when I was in... er, Junior High? No wonder I have no idea what the book about! I think it's a sign that I should spare some time to reread it. ;) Thanks for reminding me how awesome this book is, Sam! :)

    ReplyDelete
  16. I am so glad that I already own this book, because otherwise I'd probably have had to buy it instantly! Great review, this book sounds like I'd really enjoy it. :>

    Patricia

    ReplyDelete
  17. What a fantastic review, Sam! I am so glad you loved Saving Francesca, I think it's my second-fave Melina novel as well (also after OtJR). I too loved the way these kids came together as friends, it's a moment I always enjoy in YA novels. I am sure you will love The Piper's Son and Froi too!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Ah, don't kill me, but I've never read any of Melina's books! But since you love them so much, I guess I'll have to pick one up soon. Saving Francesca sounds great! The fun characters and relationships sound so awesome. You make me want to read it right nownownow. ;) Lovely review, Sam! So glad you enjoyed this book! :)

    ReplyDelete
  19. Oh man. Oh man, oh man, oh man, I NEED TO PICK UP ONE OF HER BOOKS. I'm already in love with the characters in this, JUST from what you've written. A combination of amazing review + brilliant plot = BRODIE SUFFERING EXTREME DESPERATION.

    DAMN YOU.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Why,why, WHY have I not read ANY of Melina Marchetta's books?!?! It's no secret she's a GODDESS when it comes to writing books, & I've obviously been living under a rock :/ Ahhh gosh, like Brodie, I'm already falling in love with the characters! Fantastic review Sam! I hope you get to read her other books soon :)

    ReplyDelete
  21. I've never read anything by Marchetta, but she sounds worth looking into.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I have not read this author either and I just bought ebook copies of Jellicoe Road and the Finnikin because I have heard such wonderful things. The character descriptions made me laugh...teenage dirtbag biggest slut...sounds like so much fun. I really want to read this now!

    ReplyDelete
  23. You kind of make me hate myself, what with BEING Australian, and having never read on of her books other than Alibrandi (assigned reading in school). It's even worse given one of my best friends is one of her most crazy, militant, OBSESSIVE fans. AMAZING review, as always! Oh goodness, do I love flawed, varied charactes like this :D

    ReplyDelete

Comments are more than welcome. I read and appreciate them all, so do feel free to share your thoughts. If you are unsure about something and/or are leaving a question, I will respond to within a couple of days. Be sure to check back!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...